CommentsXp Best movie ever!

Gurlyndrobb While it doesn't offer any answers, it both thrills and makes you think.

Teddie Blake The movie turns out to be a little better than the average. Starting from a romantic formula often seen in the cinema, it ends in the most predictable (and somewhat bland) way.

Quiet Muffin This movie tries so hard to be funny, yet it falls flat every time. Just another example of recycled ideas repackaged with women in an attempt to appeal to a certain audience.

fuzzhead72 I had never even heard of this movie when I saw that our local second run theater was screening it, but decided to give it a chance after watching the trailer. (and especially since it is the week before Christmas, and it seemed very relevant) I was not left with a "schmaltzy" (is that a word?) feeling of having my emotions manipulated, after watching this. The acting was spot-on and the characters were believable, thanks to the script. I really feel that the movie is one of the few to have a realistic discussion about conflict that can arise due to free speech/expression of religion on one hand, and diversity of belief on the other. It also has some entertaining subplots. When I looked over to see how my daughter was reacting, I was happy to see a big smile on her face several times during the show, so evidently she really enjoyed it as well.

marcijimlove I have posted this review because I rented this movie and enjoyed it very much. I find it interesting that the reviews that have been posted so far include the same type of sentiments or arguments that are presented in this movie. We have people who more then likely are not of a Christian faith that are highly offended and use somewhat vulgar verbiage to express their views. Then we have those of a Christian background that vehemently defend their faith. Does that not prove the timeliness of this movie? I love the reminder (presented in the film) that it is important to love those that disagree and even love them when they treat you harshly or criticize you strongly. This movies reminds us that Jesus was criticized and that we should not be surprised when we (or our godly films) are criticized in the post-modern society we live in. I do not believe you have to be a Christian to appreciate the reminder that love can warm even the hardest heart...so I believe all can enjoy this movie.

strongdoors I loved this movie... The trailer does not give justice to the true message in the story. Christians can compromise, but not on their beliefs. All people, of every religion, are encouraged to watch this movie all of the way through with open eyes. I believe the movie gives equal views from both sides. However, I must say, I am a Christian & I was very touched by the movie. It is an Excellent movie, and not just one that gives a Holiday message, but a message that should be reflected in the Christian life daily. Love others as Christ loves us. Be tolerant, compassionate, and giving. Those who comment on the politics of the movie are missing the entire point. It has nothing to do with politics. Politics are a medium for the true message being heard. I recorded this movie on my DVR and have watched it at least three times in the last two weeks. It is touching, and a lot can be learned by both "sides". The writer, Andrea Nasfell, has captured true heart felt feelings in her writings, and they are portrayed by the actors with true conviction. TWO THUMBS UP!!!!

drjimberger Having been a pastor in Alaska for 15 years, I can tell you that this state is the most un-religious state in the union. This movie portrays it as Texas-North. Sorry Brad Stein and the rest of the cast, but the reality is that you do not re-write reality for the sake of a screenplay. Yes, there is the conflict between church and state. But nowhere is that more evident than in Alaska.My experience was far different from that of the scriptwriters. The reality is that the Christians were fighting to get the creche on to public land. We learned to put it on church property, and ask the public officials to come to the dedication. In return, we would give an invocation at the community Christmas tree lighting. And yes, we use inclusive language, since we have Christians, Jews, B'hais and atheists in attendance. In towns of 4000, or 3000, you know who believes what. And you can choose to respect that, enter into dialogue and work on long-term evangelism, or shout at them in the local cafe, and go backward for the next 20 years. In a small town, there are long memories. And the stupid tirade of a pastor at the funeral of tragic death of a family, or the histrionics of a Brad Stein-character are remembered far longer than the loving grace freely given in a time of tragedy or crisis.The conflict between church and state portrayed in this film is a Texas or lower 48 phenomenon. The norms are reversed, to fit the screenwriters' ideology, not the reality of Alaska.Contrary to the characters' wishes, the First Amendment is still the First Amendment. Because Alaska is part of the United States of America. And we abide by the Constitution of the United States of America. In Alaska and the lower 48. Do you? Rev. Dr. James R. Berger Fort Myers, FL