ReaderKenka Let's be realistic.

Protraph Lack of good storyline.

FrogGlace In other words,this film is a surreal ride.

Logan By the time the dramatic fireworks start popping off, each one feels earned.

Robert Reynolds This is an early Mickey Mouse cartoon produced by the Disney studio. There will be spoilers ahead:This is a very simple, basic cartoon. Mickey is training a robot to box against a gorilla (The Kongo Killer). Mickey times the robot by playing a piano and the robot is rather uninspired until Minnie blows her car horn, at which point the robot goes amok, busting a safe, punching through a wall poster of the gorilla (and the wall it's hanging on) and going outside, knocking itself out. Minnie revives it with here horn and it goes careening off to the arena, punching wildly and furiously.Once the fight starts, the robot reverts to being tentative and uninspired. The gorilla has no such problem and basically mauls the robot, turning him almost into a junk pile. As the referee is counting him out, Minnie remembers her horn, gets it and blows it, again reviving the robot, to the point where it mops up the ring with the Kongo Killer. The robot wins in the best scene in the short. The end makes up for the somewhat slow pacing in the beginning of the short.Tis short is available on the Disney Treasures Mickey Mouse in Black and White, Volume Two DVD set. This short is worth watch at least once.

TheLittleSongbird Disney I have always loved. Mickey's Mechanical Man is not one of their best, or even Mickey's best, with a set up that once Minnie's horn sets the robot off there are no surprises about what is going to happen and an end gag that is on the weird side, but it is still very good. The animation is really top-notch, very crisp and clean and while Mickey and Minnie are very controlled in their designs it is the wonderfully kinetic and increasingly frantic movements of the robot that stand out. The music is catchy and superbly orchestrated, while the gags especially when the robot loses control are very funny and the premise- revolving around a boxing match- is silly yet clever. Mickey and Minnie continue to be likable characters, and Beppo is appropriately antagonistic but it was the robot that makes Mickey's Menchanical Man as good as it is, very well animated and the best gags of the short are with it. All in all, a very good and fun short if not one of the greats. 8/10 Bethany Cox

MartinHafer The basic plot for "Mickey's Mechanical Man" was very familiar to me, as I've seen it at least twice before in Three Stooges' shorts. While IMDb says that the plot to "Punch Drunks" (1934) was entirely written by the Stooges themselves, the film came out a year AFTER this Disney cartoon--making you wonder just how original their screenplay was. In addition, the Shemp Howard remade the film a decade later as "A Hit and a Miss". Watch the Stooges film--you'll see what I mean about the plots being virtually identical in many ways.Mickey has built a robot who is a boxer. However, the robot isn't very good and everyone assumes the Kongo Killer (a gorilla) is going to win (where is PETA when you need them?!). However, Mickey has learned a secret--when his robot hears a horn, it goes crazy and becomes amazingly aggressive--to the point where it is almost impossible to stop.The main difference between this decent but not exactly inspired cartoon and the Stooge short is that when Curly hears the song "Three Blind Mice", he goes crazy and is unstoppable. Otherwise, it's the same. I wonder, though, why repeat the Disney plot when it isn't very good in the first place?! It's only a so-so cartoon--and certainly not among the best Mickey made in this era.

wmorrow59 This is one of the strangest Disney cartoons I've encountered, so strange it feels more like a product of the Fleischer studio. In the opening moments it's established that there's going to be a boxing match between a robot (identified as Mickey's Mechanical Man) and a gorilla (called The Kongo Killer), and that's it for exposition. Next thing you know, Mickey is banging away at a piano at his training headquarters, urging the robot to punch his sparring partner—a sparring partner which happens to be a safe dangling from the ceiling, bearing a picture of the gorilla. There's no explanation for any of this, no back story, we're just expected to roll with it. Roll with it we do, and everything unfolds as it would in a crazy dream.When Minnie pulls up outside in her cute little car and tootles the horn, the Mechanical Man suddenly and inexplicably goes berserk. He bashes the dangling safe to pieces, briefly runs amok, and then collapses in a heap. Mickey nervously explains to Minnie that the sound of her horn drives the robot mad, but she laughs this off—despite what she's just witnessed—and honks again. The Mechanical Man revives and resumes running amok, this time throwing a crowd of pedestrians into a panic. Once more, the robot's crazed fit ends only when he collapses in a heap on the sidewalk, provoking contemptuous laughter from the crowd.By this point, the robot is a figure of sympathy. By technological standards he strikes us as kind of neurotic and unpredictable, and probably no match for the Kongo Killer. Suspense builds as the boxing match begins, and the contenders are introduced to the crowd. Sure enough, like all gorillas in cartoons, the Kongo Killer turns out to be a fearsome, slavering beast. (I was an adult before I learned that in reality gorillas in the wild are peaceful and even shy unless provoked, but in old-time Hollywood all the apes were angry monsters.) When Mickey's Mechanical Man is introduced he attempts to wave to the crowd but his arm falls off, prompting more laughter. The fight begins, and our hero the robot seizes an early advantage with some rhythmic punches, but the gorilla soon rises to the occasion and pummels his opponent into scrap metal. As the Mechanical Man lies semi-conscious on the mat, he envisions little mechanical birds encircling his head. Just as things look bleak, Minnie belatedly remembers that auto horn of hers and toddles out to the parking lot to retrieve it . . .I've seen a lot of Disney cartoons, but nothing else quite like this one. It all flows along smoothly enough while you're watching, but after it's over—and it ends with a genuinely weird wrap-up gag—you find yourself wondering what on earth you've just witnessed. That's the way I usually feel after experiencing some of the more surreal Betty Boop episodes. Everything about this short is Fleischer-like, from the dissolute-looking announcer who introduces the boxers to the stylized appearance of the crowd in the arena. We never find out how Mickey acquired this robot, why the car horn drives it mad, or why the poor thing is supposed to fight a gorilla in the first place. Well, I guess if they'd tried to explain any of this the short would have forfeited its quirky charm. As it stands, Mickey's Mechanical Man is perhaps the looniest product of its studio, and a worthy rival to the concurrent output of the Fleischer gang.