Protraph Lack of good storyline.

Merolliv I really wanted to like this movie. I feel terribly cynical trashing it, and that's why I'm giving it a middling 5. Actually, I'm giving it a 5 because there were some superb performances.

Hadrina The movie's neither hopeful in contrived ways, nor hopeless in different contrived ways. Somehow it manages to be wonderful

Skyler Great movie. Not sure what people expected but I found it highly entertaining.

Marcin Kukuczka Clarence Brown's production, as much classical, traditional and typical as for its period, appears to symbolize a modern approach to the sort of storytelling it evokes. Opening and closing at the Dresden Royal Opera along with its ostentatious set designs (full credit to art direction by Cedric Gibbons), it is Schumann's MUSIC that sets the tone for the entire movie and evokes its mood clearly. Yes, the fact this movie is about a musician or rather musicianS proves this assumption right – music as the major though implicit hero of the film. But with this comes something more vibrant, more vital and engrossing – passions.The unprincipled, passionate protagonists (the musicians) differ considerably as we get to know them and, speaking in far more modern sense, try to analyze them. SONG OF LOVE foremost delivers something that viewers may cherish to great extent: the fantastic combination of certain sweetness, little subtlety and desirable musicality of characters. Many IMDb reviewers have rightly observed that. Actually, what surprises us in this movie and what has not dated is an insight into driving forces within artists rather than their life stories. Seemingly, the lead belongs to Robert Schumann (1810-1856) played by the romantic hero of the movies of the period...PAUL HENREID instills an understanding of what a musical and passionate character is really like... If you remember his role in DECEPTION by Irving Rapper, he echoes that approach here. There could be no better choice for the role of Schumann who is the movie's implicit lead and explicit inspiration of Clara Schumann, his wife (Katherine Hepburn) than this actor. Henreid, capable of capturing the essence of a musician's neurotic vs. calm personality, helps the movie flee the unnecessary burden of a biopic, the haunting temptation for linear, logical type of storytelling. The musical characters are changeable, share, in a way, passions in music and passions in life but differ considerably in temper and style. Henreid handles the role with desirable effect combining inspiration. In his unforgettable scene of conducting the orchestra and choir, passion enters the screen. Now something about his female co-star, who seemingly would end up in failure when we think of combining these two.KATHERINE HEPBURN, known for a variety of roles from tomboy in ADAM'S RIB to gentle Beth in Cukor's LITTLE WOMEN, would indeed occur not a very good choice for Henreid's co-star. Yet, she crafts the role of Clara Wieck Schumann, the composer's wife and his lifelong companion and admirer with ease and slight distance. She is humorous and yet perfectly serious in moments that require these twists of emotions. Opening and closing the movie with a pompous and magnificent display of skills, she proves that the source of inspiration is music, is art – in that case, the so much cherished "Traumerai" through which she wants Schumann's genius live forever. Yet, in between the grandeur of the opening and closing, there is this ever present moral clash so typical of Code Hollywood – career vs. motherhood. She is a mother of 7 children who does not give up the duties of a mother and a wife who makes right decisions. In one scene, after the smashing musical performance, she rushes to breast feed her little baby. No one would have depicted this hurry as funnily as Ms Hepburn. Quite a vivid character. But all would be conventions within marriage, even artistic marriage if it were not for the character that supplies the movie with true mixture of spice and sweetness.ROBERT WALKER is, perhaps, the most intriguing character as Johannes Brahms – another milestone musical character of the film, sometimes placed in an inferior position to Schumann (his tutor) and sometimes in a predictable aspect of rivalry. The actor who is probably best remembered for his homo-erotic and psychologically captivating role in Hitchcock's STRANGERS ON A TRAIN, does a terrific job as a great musician and yet constantly a guest, someone coming from the background, from the mist of backdrop presence. In one terrific scene, he plays his "Wiegenlied" lullaby to Schumann's little daughter – a milestone classical piece, Walker highlights memorably the delicacy and vividness of his character. His passion, however, does not only lie in music...Among the SUPPORTING CAST, it is worth mentioning Else Janssen as Bertha the cook who holds some humorous reliefs of the movie and Henry Daniell as Franz Liszt, the last composer character of the film who delivers a bravura performance and portrays a neurotic essence and talent blending with a bit of madness. It's a pity that there is no single mention of Frederic Chopin.The artistry of the movie beautifully delivers Clarence Brown's direction style. Garbo's favorite director, he displays certain features that echo CAMILLE or ANNA KARENINA. But full credit for cinematographer Harry Strandling who handles everything with flair for details, beauty and accurate aesthetics.SONG OF LOVE is an artfully and musically inspired movie that stands as a modern approach and a passionate product of its time. A gem highly worth seeing which brings the music and the passions of artists and within artists vividly to life. 8/10

rgcarterx1 I read a biography of Robert Schumann (over 40 years ago) and it was an interesting story of Robert and Clara . . . but good ole Hollywood . . . they take a story of real people and "base" a movie on it. Here is a movie of three extraordinarily talented musicians and about the only thing in this movie that reminded me of them was the fact that it had characters named "Robert Schumann", "Clara Schumann" and "Johannas Brahms". It has two great actors, Paul Henreid and Katherine Hepburn, who have been in some fine movies. In this one, I don't see Robert and Clara Schumann and Johannes Brahms . . . I see Paul Henreid, Katherine Hepburn and Robert Walker running around spouting Hollywood lines. What a shame . . . they could have made a great movie about three great musicians.

edwagreen Beautiful music is the highlight of this nice 1947 film dealing with the lives of Robert and Clara Schumann.Katharine Hepburn gives a restrained, but compelling performance as Clara, the woman who gave up a promising career to marry Schumann and subsequently have 7 children with him. The early scenes are comic viewing Hepburn as a mother of 7 attempting to rear the children. I thought I'd see the famous cooking scene repeated in Hepburn's 1942 film- "Woman of the Year."Paul Henried is in fine form as the brilliant music professor who was plagued with mental problems. In comes Robert Walker as Johannes Brahms. He has come to study with Schumann and moves in with the family. His love for Clara shall eventually drive him away only for him to come back to her several years after Schumann's death.There is an interesting performance by Leo G. Carroll as Clara's domineering father. There is a court scene as Carroll objects to his daughter marrying Robert. What would Womens Lib think about this?

harry-76 Considering this screenplay was for a major film studio and geared for the general public, rather than professional musicians or scholars, the five writers who contributed to the script did a decent job.Centered in the enactment is that of Clara Wieck, played fervently by Katherine Hepburn, who enjoyed a full life of commitment to her composer husband Robert Schumann, large family and artistic ideals.Clara's strength held the household together, which included border composer Johannes Brahms, played earnestly by Robert Walker. Paul Henried has the difficult assignment of portraying Robert, a musical genius suffering from depression. Whereas today medication easily placates these symptoms, in the 19th century, people just had to suffer from the ailment, which affected all those around. Henried manages the role with sensitivity. Clara was known to eschew technical "brilliance" that was the earmark of Franz Liszt, and in one telling scene she conveys her embodiment of "loving simplicity" over Lisztian "show." It's a provoking moment that conjures relevance today, where "young piano whiz kids" often may play up a storm technically, while seldom penetrating the spiritual heart of the score. Clara apparently was one of the strongest women of the 19th century, in a male-dominated society, successfully surmounting a father's legal challenge of her marriage, the deaths of a number of her children, and a husband who constantly needed attention--all the while composing, arranging, and giving concerts. In a touching scene Walker's Jonannes admits to his love for Hepburn's Clara. It's not a far-fetched scene, according to musicologists, though there's hardly concrete proof for substantiation. The film is rich in the works of Brahms, Schumann and Liszt, and Hepburn and Henry Danielle (as Liszt) do commendable physical renderings of mock piano playing to sublime recordings of Artur Rubenstein. Clarence Brown directs with his usual sure hand.