Smartorhypo Highly Overrated But Still Good

Hadrina The movie's neither hopeful in contrived ways, nor hopeless in different contrived ways. Somehow it manages to be wonderful

Ariella Broughton It is neither dumb nor smart enough to be fun, and spends way too much time with its boring human characters.

Tayyab Torres Strong acting helps the film overcome an uncertain premise and create characters that hold our attention absolutely.

MartinHafer Despite having Joel McCrea in the lead, this is a rather dull western...dull and pretty predictable. About the only part that was unexpected was how less than honorable McCrea's character was through much of the movie.The story is set during the Civil War. Three buddies all arrive in Yankee occupied Texas on the lookout for Cottrell (Victor Jory). Cottrell is fashioned after the real life Civil War raider, Quantrill...though oddly he's fighting for the Union in this one. Despite Kip Davis (Joel McCrea) and his friends wanting to kill Cottrell, soon Lee (Douglas Kennedy) joins the Confederate army and Kip and Charlie (Zachary Scott) help the South by running the blockades. Eventually, however, Charlie comes to enjoy getting rich much more than helping the Confederacy and this brings a very predictable showdown at the end.Everything about this film is mediocre at best and the story only occasionally interesting. I had a hard time caring about the characters and the story.

zardoz-13 "Coroner Creek" director Ray Enright's Civil War-era western "South of St. Louis" ranks as both entertaining and distinctive for the three Texas cattle ranchers (Joel McCrea, Zachary Scott, and Douglas Kennedy) who share a bond of kinship as stout as brotherhood. This heroic threesome is symbolic because their communal ranch, called 'The Three Bell Ranch,' is burned down by the villainous likes of Victor Jory and his raiders. Jory's Luke Cottrell is equivalent to the murderous William Quantrill who committed atrocities galore. Kip Davis (Joel McCrea of "The Virginian"), Charlie Burns (Zachary Scott of "Mildred Pierce," and Lee Price (Douglas Kennedy of "Dark Passage") all wear one small bell attached to their spurs. The first glimpse we get of this trio in action occurs they corner obnoxious Yankee guerrilla fighter Luke Cottrell in a Brownsville, Texas, saloon. Kip refuses to slap leather with the evil Cottrell. Nevertheless, he sheds his gun belt and batters Cottrell into submission with his fists before he banishes the brigand from Texas. The American Civil War that spawned Cottrell shatters the solidarity of our three protagonists. Lee decides to enlist in the Confederacy and dons a gray uniform. Meanwhile, Kip and Charlie enter the gunrunning business. The color of their hats reflects the morality of their characters. For example, Lee wears a white hat, while Charlie sports black headgear. Kip comes up in the middle with a brown one. Indeed, Lee is virtue incarnate; Charlie is malevolent incarnate, while Kip stands somewhere between them. During all these early shenanigans, we see Kip and his future wife Deborah Miller (Dorothy Malone of "The Big Sleep") delay their marriage plans indefinitely because the three men aim to punish Cottrell for his act of arson. "Humoresque" scenarist Zachary Gold and "The Big Country" writer James R. Webb have drummed-up a historical oater that chronicles the way that the Civil War fractures the tight bond among the three. The other recurring character--introduced later--that takes a fancy to Kip is red-haired, dance-hall warbler Rouge de Lisle (Alexis Smith of "Gentleman Jim") who dresses seductively and knows how to belt out a song. Confederate sympathizers will like the way that the rebels triumph over Union. This rugged western shoot'em up is a mite more complicated because it thrusts Kip into a predicament. Charlie and he are running guns across the Texas/Mexico line dressed up in stolen Union outfits when Confederates attack them. Initially, Kip refuses to return fire, but Charlie convinces him otherwise. German lenser Karl Freund of "Metropolis" is responsible for the exemplary cinematography.

bsmith5552 "South of St. Louis" takes place during the American Civil War in Texas near the Mexican border.Three ranchers Kip Davis (Joel McCrea), Charlie Burns (Zachary Scott) and Lee Price (Douglas Kennedy) partner in a ranch called "The Three Bells). Each man wears a small bell attached to their spurs to signify their partnership. While away, the ranch is attacked and burned by a gang of raiders led by Luke Cottrell (Victor Jory). The ranchers vow to track down Cottrell. Kip leaves his girl Deb Miller (Dorothy Malone) behind to pursue the outlaws.The boys become acquainted with saloon singer Rouge de Lisle (Alexis Smith) whom they discover is in the gun running business supplying arms to the Confederates from Mexico. Kip and Charlie decide to join her while Lee joins the Confederate army. Charlie along with his henchman Slim Hansen (Bob Steele) decide to keep at it while Kip wants to return to "Three Bells" and begin rebuilding however he learns that Deb will not be returning with him.Anyway, fast forward to the end of the war and we find that Lee is now a Texas Ranger and Kip is drowning his sorrows in Mexico with Rouge at his side. Charlie and Slim meanwhile have kept the gun running profitable. Lee is assigned to clean up the gang but is alone in the task. Will Kip come to Lee's rescue? Will there be a final showdown? Of course there will.Joel McCrea is well, Joel McCrea giving his usual even performance in the lead. He has a good fight scene with Jory along the way. You just know that the Zachary Scott character is going to turn bad at some point. Douglas Kennedy who usually played villains, gets to be on the right side of the law for a change. Alexis Smith is OK as the saloon singer/gun runner and Dorothy Malone is sweet as the girl he left behind.Bob Steele after his "B" western starring roles ended moved on to mostly playing villains. He is a scheming knife throwing double crosser in this one. And watch for his scene stealing death scene.Also in the cast for limited comedy relief is Alan Hale as Jake Evarts the saloon owner. Western fans will also spot veteran bad guy Harry Woods in a brief appearance as a recruiting sergeant.

alexandre michel liberman (tmwest) Joel McCrea, Zachary Scott and Douglas Kennedy are friends that get separated during the civil war. McCrea is going to marry Dorothy Malone, but he leaves her to find the outlaw that had destroyed his ranch.(Victor Jory). He ends up meeting Alexis Smith (great as always) who falls in love with him. Colorful and entertaining, directed by Ray Enright who was very good in this type of films.