TrueHello
Fun premise, good actors, bad writing. This film seemed to have potential at the beginning but it quickly devolves into a trite action film. Ultimately it's very boring.
Beulah Bram
A film of deceptively outspoken contemporary relevance, this is cinema at its most alert, alarming and alive.
neilmack-16250
Shameful film making. This is a really important narrative but the filmmakers are more concerned with imposing their style on the story. It's an exercise in career development when it should be a compassionate exposition and discussion of a nuanced issue. All edits. No details. The filmmakers need to have a long hard look at themselves in order to decide who and what they're trying to protect. The fact this is currently scoring above 8 leads me to despair of any real fundamental change.
camillacoy
Every single person who had a hand in this young man's incarceration and, ultimately, his death, should be ashamed. Unfortunately, they never are. In particular, Judge DiMango. As an officer of the court, she had the burden of protecting Kalief's rights. I do not care that the state of New York's court system is overwhelmed. She was notorious for scaring defendants into taking plea deals in order to get cases off her docket quickly. She did not care that the person may actually be innocent; that was beside the point. She wanted to keep her reputation of being a bully intact. Shame on her. I will never watch her ridiculous TV show again. She portrays herself as a funny, charismatic person.And while those things may or may not be true, her dark side is the part of her that should keep her awake at night.
Kenyae Kofi
This document series was very crazy. I personally have been racially profiled! This series shows that America is a joke and needs to be ready and willing to progress as a nation and wrongful convictions is no way to go about it. This also shows that we not only need a better jail system but a better government system. Kalief Browder was completely destroyed after this mistreatment over a damn book bag that may have or may not have been robbed by him. The system needs to be changed to a spot where we make criminals change as individuals to sane people if possible and that we don't arrest people for no unlawful reasons. When watching this series I was terrified and I felt like I was watching a suspense or horror series where someone was going to die. I don't think anyone should go through this and hopefully the system gets better to help people instead of making them worse off then what they were.
timmyhollywood
For me, there are two ways to rate this docu-series. The first is on an emotional or abstract level. The second is purely technical.This six-part documentary, or docu-series, somewhat follows in the line of other true crime docu-series of late such as the Making a Murderer about Steven Avery or The Jinx, on Robert Durst. There aren't as many "twists" as with the Steven Avery story – Browder's is pretty straightforward. But the structure of storytelling is so noticeable so as to be distracting. Each episode follows a formula: presage the episode, then conflict builds to a climax, then a summary of the episode, then a teaser of the next episode, all woven together in a highly stylized way. As this pattern repeats, you hear certain sound bites more than once, you see the same pieces of footage again and again interpolated with close-ups of speeded-up clocks, to the point I wondered if I'd inadvertently replayed an episode. I found myself thinking that the whole thing was stretched out to fill six episodes when three would have contained it – the length of a feature film.At the same time, this repetitiveness might be deliberate, meant to achieve an emotional end rather than just keep the brain stimulated and interested – we hear Browder tell ABC's Nightline at least a dozen times that he refused to plead guilty because he didn't do anything. We hear Van Jones say more than once how Browder wasn't a perfect person, but the position he took was perfect. We see the same security footage from Rikers multiple times, reinforcing the brutality of the experience. It's not enough, the filmmakers seem to be saying, to show you this just once. You're going to have an experience that evokes the experience Browder himself had – an endless string of court dates leading to adjournment, repetitive violence; system inadequacy on multiple levels ad nauseam. So, in this way, the film's technique is effective.Some cynical viewers are likely to say, then, that it's the manipulation of the filmmakers which provoke an emotional response to sympathize with Browder and his ordeal. I don't think so. I think the filmmakers used the medium to present some small sliver of what his ordeal was like so there was something – beyond a kneejerk judgement – to truly sympathize *with.* It's an old trope – "I'm gonna put the *system* on trial!" – but it's never been more apposite than it is in the case of Kalief Browder. We could simply be told – in a short news article or even in an internet meme – that 97% of criminal cases go to plea bargain, that due to a limited number of judges and criminal defense attorneys, without plea bargaining, the system would collapse. We could be told, then, that if a man claims he's innocent of an allegation (theft of a backpack), and gets denied bail because he broke probation by being arrested for allegedly stealing said backpack, and then languishes in one of the most violent prisons in the world while exercising his constitutional right to a trial… for THREE YEARS – just knowing these facts doesn't pack the full punch of sitting through the footage of Browder getting gang-beaten or witnessing his mother break down on camera. Van Jones, at one point observes that, like with Syria, the casualties are "just a number" until one child washes up on a beach – then the world takes notice. Jones says, "Browder is that baby." Certainly Browder got the world to pay attention to the major flaws in the New York criminal justice system. But I like what someone else says in the documentary even better – that Browder, in standing up for his rights and refusing to cop a plea for something he says he didn't do, no matter how bad the violence of jail, the torture of endless months of solitary confinement, acts like America's last true patriot. And I think this is where, today more than ever, America needs to really come to terms with itself in defining and understanding what patriotism really is. 10/10 stars.
